[2001] International Fisheries Bulletin No. 10

New agreement to protect endangered seabirds is concluded in Cape Town

In early February this year, negotiations were successfully concluded on the text of a new international treaty, the Agreement on the Conservation of Albatrosses and Petrels (ACAP). The new Agreement, which was negotiated within the framework of the Bonn Convention on Migratory Species, was adopted following a week-long meeting hosted by the South African Government in Cape Town. Attending countries came from both the Northern and Southern Hemispheres, including several from South America. Both albatross and petrel range states and nations with fishing fleets that interact with these highly threatened seabirds were represented. This article provides a general overview of the Agreement, with special reference to the provisions relevant to fisheries.

Albatrosses have the highest proportion of threatened species of any bird family, making them the most imperiled of all the world's seabirds. Up to 26 species of albatross and petrel could become extinct unless firm steps are taken to reverse the destructive effects of uncontrolled longline fishing, pollution, habitat degradation, human disturbance of breeding sites and introduced diseases and predators. Of the 24 species of albatross, 21 species have declining populations, or have populations of unknown status. About 50% of albatross populations contain fewer than 100 breeding pairs, making albatrosses extremely susceptible to random events or even low levels of mortality.

When all the species of albatross and seven species of petrel from the Southern Hemisphere were listed on the Appendices of the Bonn Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species, it was a recognition that urgent international cooperation was needed to improve their threatened conservation status. Following the listings, governments, led by Australia and others in the Valdivia Group of Southern Hemisphere Countries for the Environment, embarked on discussions to develop the Agreement. The Cape Town meeting followed on from an earlier negotiation meeting held in Hobart, Australia in July 2000.

The Agreement is based on Article IV(3) of the Bonn Convention, which provides that parties to the Convention "shall endeavour to conclude AGREEMENTS where these would benefit the species" listed on the Bonn Convention Appendices. The Agreement, which includes an Action Plan, describes a number of conservation measures to be implemented by signatories to the proposed text. These include research and monitoring, reduction of incidental mortality in fisheries, eradication of non-native species at breeding sites (especially introduced predators such as rats and cats), reduction of disturbance and habitat loss, and reducing pollution. In addition, parties are to prohibit, subject to certain limited exceptions, the deliberate taking of, or harmful interference with, albatrosses and petrels, their eggs or their breeding sites. 

ACAP and fisheries

The stated general objective of the Agreement is to achieve and maintain a favourable conservation status for albatrosses and petrels (Article II(1)). This is to be achieved by applying the general conservation measures contained in the main body of the Agreement, the specific measures contained in the Action Plan, which is annexed to the Agreement but forms an integral part of it, and through the application of the precautionary approach, in particular by not allowing lack of full scientific certainty to be used as a reason for postponing measures where there are threats of serious or irreversible adverse impacts or damage (Article II(3)). With one exception, the general measures do not directly concern fisheries, although many of the provisions are nevertheless of relevance, including the development and implementation of measures to prevent, remove, minimize or mitigate the adverse effects of activities that may influence the conservation status of albatrosses and petrels; to ensure the existence and appropriateness of training for, inter alia, the implementation of conservation measures; and support of the implementation of actions elaborated under the FAO International Plan of Action for Reducing Incidental Catch of Seabirds in Longline Fisheries (Article III).

The most detailed conservation measures, however, are set forth in an Action Plan, reproduced in an annex to the Agreement (Annex 2). The Action Plan is based around seven key areas:

bulletspecies conservation;
bullethabitat conservation and restoration;
bulletmanagement of human activities;
bulletresearch and monitoring;
bulletcollation of information;
bulleteducation and public awareness; and 
bulletimplementation.

A number of aspects are relevant to fisheries and marine management. Thus, the measures on species and habitat conservation include obligations to manage marine habitats so as to ensure the sustainability of marine living resources that provide food for albatrosses and petrels and the section on the management of human activities includes obligations to avoid pollution that may harm albatrosses and petrels and to reduce pollution and disturbance from human activities, such as tourism (Annex 2, Parts 1, 2, 3.3 and 3.4). Of most relevance to fisheries, however, are a number of measures set out in relation to incidental mortality in fisheries (Annex 2, Part 3.2). These include obligations to:

bullettake appropriate measures to reduce or eliminate the mortality of albatrosses and petrels resulting incidentally from fishing activities;
bullet to consider, in relation to fishing activities under the auspices of regional fisheries organizations, information and evaluations from such organizations and to adopt the measures agreed by such organizations for reducing the incidental taking of albatrosses and petrels;
bullet encourage the institutions of and participants in relevant international treaties or organizations to give effect to the objective of the agreement; and
bulletendeavour to adopt additional measures to combat illegal, unregulated and unreported fishing activities that may have an adverse effect on albatrosses and petrels.

The decision-making body of the Agreement will be the Meeting of the Parties, to meet ordinarily at intervals of not more than three years, and there will also be an Advisory Committee, to provide scientific, technical and other advice and information and to make recommendations concerning the Action Plan and the implementation of the Agreement, and a Secretariat. Further subsidiary bodies may also be established. In the event of a dispute, a mechanism is provided for disputes which are agreed to be of a technical nature to be referred, as a matter of last resort, to a technical arbitrational panel which can deliver a binding decision on the parties to the dispute. In the case of other disputes between parties to the Agreement, the provisions of Article XIII of the Bonn Convention are to apply, regardless of whether or not the parties to the dispute are also parties to the Convention. (Under the Convention, any dispute is to be settled in the first place by negotiation between the parties involved and, of that turns out to be unsuccessful, the dispute may be submitted to arbitration, in particular that of the Permanent Court of Arbitration at The Hague, whose decision shall be binding on the parties).

The Agreement will enter into force on the first day of the third month following the signature without reservation in respect of ratification, acceptance or approval or the deposit of instruments of ratification, acceptance or approval by five Range States. It is hoped that this will occur in early 2002. The initial response to the Agreement has, indeed, been positive. The Head of the UK Delegation at the negotiating meeting stressed his Government’s commitment to the Agreement, stating: “We are delighted to have been able to offer support for this important meeting, and at the successful outcome of the negotiations”. The Agreement was also well-received by NGOs represented at the meeting. Mr David Pritchard, representing BirdLife International, expressed satisfaction with the outcome of the negotiations and called for countries to begin implementing the terms of the Agreement immediately, without waiting for the formality of entry into force.

John Cooper
Chief Research Officer, Avian Demography Unit, University of Cape Town
jcooper@botzoo.uct.za

Chris Hedley
Editor, International Fisheries Bulletin and Internet Guide to International Fisheries Law
chris@oceanlaw.net 

    
Related links

Text of the Bonn Convention

FAO International Plan of Action for Reducing Incidental Catch of Seabirds in Longline Fisheries

CMS Press Release, 2 February 2001

WildLife Australia: Albatrosses 
Selection on information on developments from the Australian environmental ministry, including:

bullet Report on a Meeting to discuss an Agreement on the Conservation of Southern Hemisphere Albatrosses and Petrels (July 2000 meeting in Hobart)

The conservation of South African seabirds, with special reference to the role of international instruments
Another relevant article by John Cooper, reproduced on the Cape Nature Conservation website